Draft Position Isn’t All That Links Esiason and Dalton

Posted by Dan Hoard on September 19, 2011 – 10:52 pm

In 1984, the Bengals selected Boomer Esiason in the second round of the draft with the 38th overall pick.

This year, Cincinnati chose Andy Dalton in the second round with the 35th overall pick.

Courtesy of Associated Press

My broadcasting partner Dave Lapham has watched both quarterbacks from the booth and sees some similarities.

“I think they both have a chip on their shoulder that they weren’t drafted in the first round and I think that they play that way,” said Lapham.  “Boomer definitely played that way and I think Andy Dalton does too.  The other thing I noticed about Andy Dalton is how effective he is on the sideline – firing his teammates up and approaching the game with a linebacker’s mentality.  That was Boomer Esiason.  He had the swagger and he challenged guys and backed it up.  Andy seemed to do that up in Denver, so I think there are a lot of similarities.”

After two games, Dalton has a quarterback rating of 105.7.  In Boomer’s final season (1997) with the Bengals, he had a QB rating of 106.9.

* * * * *

As feared after the Denver game, wide receiver Jordan Shipley will miss the rest of the season with a torn ACL.

“You know where (Shipley) is going to be on the field all of the time,” said quarterbacks coach Ken Zampese.  “There’s a certainty with him and that’s been really enjoyable to have.”    

“It takes away a security blanket that Andy Dalton had,” said Lapham.  “When you’re in a third down situation, you have to totally be able to trust your slot guy.  If you have trust in that guy and know that he is exactly where he is supposed to be, it gives you great comfort at the quarterback position.   That’s a tough thing for Andy Dalton to lose as a rookie.”

Andre Caldwell becomes the Bengals primary slot receiver and rookie Ryan Whalen is a candidate to be activated on game day for the first time to provide depth.

“You never want to see someone get hurt and Jordan Shipley means a lot to this team because he’s a great player and person,” said Whalen.  “The way that he creates separation with his shiftiness and some of the moves that he makes in the slot are really helpful to watch, because he can get open against guys that are really good players.  Even though I wasn’t playing, I’ve prepared for the opportunity and if it comes, I’ll make the most of it and do the best that I can.”

* * * * *

I hope you’ll join Dave Lapham and me for Bengals Game Plan on Wednesday night from 6 to 8 on ESPN 1530-AM.

I’d love to hear from you at

If you Twitter, you can follow my tweets at

And I’m on Facebook.  Just search for Dan Hoard and look for the photo of me with the handsome lad.

Posted in Heard It From Hoard | 4 Comments »

A Blown Chance, But A Bright Future

Posted by Dan Hoard on September 19, 2011 – 1:52 am

It was a frustrating loss…a blown opportunity to be alone in first place in the AFC North…against an opponent so depleted by injuries that Tim Tebow made a cameo as America’s most famous emergency receiver.

Courtesy of Associated Press

So why don’t I feel lousy about it?

Because of Andy Dalton, A.J. Green, and Jerome Simpson.

In his 2nd NFL start, Dalton was 27-for-41 for 332 yards, 2 TD, and 0 INT.  Green caught 10 of those passes for 124 yards and a spectacular toe-tapping TD.  And Simpson had 4 grabs for 136 yards – his 3rd 120-yard receiving performance in his last 4 games. 

“You can’t say enough about what those guys did,” said cornerback Leon Hall.  “We got off to a bad start and they were able to fire back and keep us in this game.”

After passing for 52 yards in the first half, Dalton threw for 280 yards after intermission.  Nearly all of his intermediate throws were right on the money, with the exception of a key 3rd-and-8 pass against a blitz in the 4th quarter that was slightly behind Simpson.  A completion would have put the Bengals well within the range of Mike Nugent for a go-ahead field goal attempt.

Courtesy of Associated Press

“I’m a professional receiver and I’m supposed to make those catches,” Simpson told me.  “It was just a little bit behind me, but I’m pretty flexible and I make those catches all the time.  I didn’t look it all the way in and we had to the punt the ball right there in a key situation.”

“Nobody’s perfect,” said Dalton.  “Everybody’s going to have a drop, everyone’s going to make a mistake, but he played pretty good.”

After two NFL starts, Dalton has completed 66% of his passes for 3 TD and 0 INT for a quarterback rating of 105.7.

“He is primed to be great,” said A.J. Green.  “His composure, his confidence, and the way he can throw the ball to everybody.”

“He’s not playing like a rookie – he’s playing like a veteran,” said Simpson.  “The guy is poised and he’s a great quarterback man.  I’ve got to help him out and make big plays for him because he’s throwing strikes to us and putting the ball where it needs to be.” 

While the Bengals made several big plays, their inability to convert on 3rd-and-short cost them the game.  Cincinnati was 1-for-11 on third down conversations, including three failed attempts on 3rd-and-1.

“1 for 11?  You can’t win football games like that,” said Simpson.

But you can learn from it.  And with the youngest roster in the AFC and the third-youngest in the NFL, the Bengals have plenty of room to grow. 

“We had a couple of chances late in the game to win, but we didn’t finish and that’s something that we have to do,” said Domata Peko.  “With a young team like this and a young quarterback, we have to learn how to finish these games off.  We made a lot of mistakes, but we still had a chance to win.”

“We definitely have to learn from this and come out next week and start a lot faster,” said Hall.

“There are a lot of young guys on this offense and we’re learning,” said Green.  “We are going to go out there and fight every week.”

* * * * *

I’d love to hear from you at

If you Twitter, you can follow my tweets at

And I’m on Facebook.  Just search for Dan Hoard and look for the photo of me with the handsome lad.

Posted in Heard It From Hoard | 2 Comments »